Should I reupholster an antique chair or keep the original fabric?

If the original upholstery is in decent shape, keeping it is often the better choice for value. Some collectors care a great deal about original fabric, stuffing and tacking, and early upholstery can provide clues about a chair's age and history.

If the fabric is torn, stained or the padding has collapsed, reupholstery is common and widely accepted, especially for chairs that will be used. Ask an upholsterer who works with antiques to use methods that protect the frame, such as reusing existing tack holes when possible rather than adding many new ones. Traditional materials may also be more appropriate than modern foam for older pieces.

Keep a sample of the original fabric and take photos before work begins. If the chair may be valuable, check with an appraiser or auctioneer first, since a buyer may prefer it untouched.