What should I do if I bought a fake at an auction?

First, review the auction company's terms and conditions. Many auctions sell items as-is, but some offer guarantees on authenticity or allow returns for items that were materially misdescribed. The terms usually explain time limits and how to file a claim.

Contact the auction company promptly and politely with your concerns, along with photos and any expert opinion you have. Reputable companies care about their reputation and may resolve the issue, especially if the catalog description was inaccurate.

If the matter cannot be resolved, options may include a payment dispute through your card issuer, a complaint to your state's consumer protection office or auctioneer licensing board, or legal action. Rules and remedies vary by state, so consider talking with an attorney before taking formal steps. In the future, ask questions before bidding and get a professional opinion on expensive items.