How do I tell if a cast iron toy is old or a reproduction?

Cast iron toys like banks, horse-drawn wagons and cars were popular in the late 1800s and early 1900s, and many have been reproduced. Originals usually have tight, smooth castings where the parts fit together well, with fine detail. Reproductions are often cast from an original, which makes them slightly smaller, rougher and less detailed, with gaps where the pieces join.

Look at the paint and wear. Original paint wears naturally on the high points and edges that would have been handled, while reproductions often have fake aging that looks even or appears in odd places. Rust on a reproduction may look orange and fresh rather than dark and settled. Screws and rivets should match the period, and modern Phillips screws are a warning sign.

Compare your toy with photos of known originals in toy reference books. Mechanical banks especially are heavily reproduced. If a toy seems valuable, a toy specialist or auction company that sells antique toys can examine it before you buy or sell.