Does replacing old hardware lower the value of antique furniture?

It can. For many antiques, original hardware is part of what collectors are paying for, and replacements are one of the first things an experienced buyer checks. Extra filled holes, mismatched screws, or shadows of a different pull on the wood all tell the story that something was changed.

The effect depends on the piece. On high-end or rare furniture, replaced hardware may reduce value noticeably. On everyday older furniture bought to use, period-appropriate replacements may make little difference and can even help a piece sell if the originals were broken or missing.

If you are unsure, talk with an appraiser or an experienced antique furniture dealer before making changes. When replacements are already in place, disclose them when selling. Honest description builds trust and protects you from returns or disputes later.